Song Choices a la Top 3

Idol on tomorrow, top 3, woowoo, so let's look at the competition.... and results may surprise...


DAVID COOK: ...Consistant...Original....Refreshing, this guy has taken everything from Mariah the Pariah thru to Lionel Richie to The Beatles and given them the best improvements, making even critics of Idol take note.
Why should he win? Simply, he's the best of the contestants left, has been since Michael left, his unique take on popular songs leaves the imagination open for what else he's going to pull out of his sleeve, then to come out and sing Music On The Night straight whilst his "arch" enemy David A ruined another Phantom classic.

I'm a HUGE fan of Phantom and was sooo dissappointed by Fartchuleta's 'Think Of Me' abomination.

Why shouldn't he win? Exactly, why shouldn't he win?

Song Choices? Blondie's Rip Her To Shreds. Placebo's cover of Running Up That Hill, or even The Kids Aren't Alright by The Offspring.

SYESHA MERCADO: ....Generic....Hit and Miss....Jazz Cat over Ballad Rat, Syesha has surprised us all and beaten the odds to gain a spot in the Top 3, only time will tell is this was a worthy decision.

Why should she win? Well, she's been somewhat hit, somewhat miss, the occasional jazz number however isn't enough to overshadow the boring generic song chocies, been there done that. Jazzy she can be cool though.

Why shouldn't she win? Do we need to repeat ourselves? The thing about Syesha is that even when she falls she rises, it's up and down, but she's gotten this far which is a true testament to her tenacity and her fan base support. A spot next to Cook at the finale would be better deserved than other certain contestants.

Song Choices? Sober by Kelly Clarkson, Too Hard Too Handle by whoever originated it, or perhaps even Here's Where I Stand from Camp.

DAVID ARCHULETA: .....popular....young....questionable... Daddys favourite son is doing him prouder than your average.

Why should he win? He has the young teen vote, but as we know with these shows, the parents pay the phone bill, the adults get to vote.

Why shouldn't he win? He shouldn't. He doesn't deserve it, his father has been milking his son for all his worth, show after show after show, trying to become famous, and America is just giving the cunt of a man (the dad) what he wants. Stage parents don't deserve to have successful kids.

Song choices? Walk The Dinosaur, hehehe the Tin Lids did this years ago. Actually, whatever he sings will sound like the week before it, so who cares really?


DAVID COOK TO WIN, WOOWOO!